Young Thurgood Marshall faces one of his greatest challenges while working as a lawyer for the NAACP. All Rights Reserved. Adoring fans presented their "sturdy youths" with picayune gold footballs for their watch chains. He threw her into the water to "get rid of her," and she said she was able to take off her heavy fur coat and undo the ropes that bound her legs. After the innocent verdict was rendered and Spell was given his freedom, he would eventually move to East Orange, New Jersey where he spent the rest of his life with his common-law wife, Virgus Clark. Miss Fannie claimed a Black man broke into her home and attacked her. When they reached the Kensico Reservoir, she asked him to stop and then got out of the car, jumped a guardrail, and ran downwards an beach. With white men and colored women, however, the unwritten law is usually forgotten" (per Smithsonian Magazine). "I was afraid that if I went toward her, she might hurt herself." The Juilliard-trained saxophonist and singer-songwriter talks about his new album and the process that went into making it. He was a no-good S.O.B., that's what he was." On his first day of employment with the Strubings, Joseph Spell was arrested for threatening to hurt a former employer when she wouldn't loan him money. He was released from prison in 1946. I told 'em get out of my office.". In fact, Friedman's family has spoken out against this and other fabrications in the movie. "He was supposed to have raped this woman four times in one night," recalled Marshall. Xxx-one at the time of his arrest, he and his common-law wife, a childhood friend named Virgis Clark, lived in the attic of the Strubing estate. . Yet even the car ride was making her nervous of being discovered. Yes. The woman, Eleanor Strubing, then 32, was a former model and the wife of an advertising executive. As depicted in the film, Marshall attended college with Langston Hughes, who he remained friends with after college. They had been shut out of factory and union jobs, leading many to turn to domestic service for income. Off went the girdle once again, and, in Spell's words, they "had business" in the car. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Eleanor Strubing, portrayed by Kate Hudson, was a white woman married to a wealthy advertising executive who accused her African-American chauffeur/butler, Joseph Spell, of raping her multiple. Her claim that she was raped four times in one night by the same man, though possible, also raised suspicions. He, besides, was a chauffeur. Starring Chadwick Boseman, Josh Gad, Kate Hudson, Copyright 2023 HistoryvsHollywood.com, CTF Media, Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile. "My uncle was never beaten up by anyone, especially racist thugs," wrote Roger Friedman, Sam's nephew who runs the movie website Showbiz411. According to the 2001 Tulsa Race Riot Commission Report via The Washington Post, Rowland was accused of assaulting Page on a public elevator in broad daylight." I guess we argued five out of seven nights at the dinner table.". Over several decades, Marshall argued and won a variety of cases to strike down many forms of legalized racism, helping to inspire the American civil rights movement" (viaBiography). The human being and so jump and gagged her, she said, drove to the reservoir, pushed her off a span, and pelted her with rocks. Witness later on witness emphasized how distraught Strubing appeared on the morning time of Dec xi. As Spell said in the film "Marshall," white mobs lynched Black men for being accused of raping white women. In real life, Marshall, Friedman, the judge, and the jury all received hate mail, including death threats and graphic pictures of lynchings during the Spell trial (per Legal Affairs). In reality, they were not in court for the verdict. Despite claims he would move back to Louisiana, according to Legal Affairs, Spell only moved to East Orange, New Jersey, where he lived with his common-law wife until he died in 1968. In the film, Joseph Spell was accused of stealing by his previous employer, but according to Legal Affairs, "The day before he started with the Strubings, Spell had been arrested and had received a suspended sentence for threatening to hurt a former employer unless she gave him a small loan." Thurgood Marshall was the first African-American to serve on the U.S. Supreme Court after being appointed by President Johnson in 1967. Marshall attended Howard University for law school and he graduated magna cum laude in 1933. One was an elderly clergyman who was challenged by the state and removed. But if the group'southward members were too poor to contribute much, many of them chosen the NAACP to thank Marshall for defending Spell. Fannies fraudulent tears were the excuse these envious hellions needed to purge their rage. Although the death penalty in rape cases was rare and contingent upon other criteria, the Supreme Court did not ban it until 1977 with Coker v. Georgia, when Marshall himself was a justice on the court. "The verdict leaves the women of America at the mercy of anyone who may seek their ruin," Eleanor said (Lima News). In the pre-dawn hours of December 11, two truck drivers, Henry Herlihy and Samuel Caesar, discovered her on the reservoir's edge in a semi-hysterical condition, her clothing drenched (The Philadelphia Inquirer). Later 16 hours of interrogation, a prosecutor announced that Spell had confessed. Similar to the Exonerated Five, that one accusation stole the innocence of nine Black children. What followed was a re-enactment of erstwhile myths of white womanhood and black aggression that NAACP Secretary Walter White described as "expected in Mississippi, but not in Connecticut." Rihannas Puma x Fenty Is Coming Back Heres Where You Can Still Buy Those Cult-Fave Creepers, JetSuiteX Donating Portion of Sales to Southern California Wildfire Relief Efforts, Industry Panel Suggests Ways to Better Represent Muslims in Film and TV, 'Marshall' Cast Celebrates First Thurgood Marshall Day With Students Nationwide, Head of U.K.s Film and TV Charity, Which Played Crucial Role in Highlighting Mental Health Crisis, to Step Down, Will Smith Returns to Awards Stage for the First Time Since the 2022 Oscars, How Judd Hirsch Made the Most of Short Fabelmans Screen Time, and Nabbed an Oscar Nom to Boot, Ana de Armas on the Polarizing Views on Blonde: It Was Not Made to Please People, All Quiet on the Western Front, Elvis, Empire of Light Cinematographers on Their Oscar-Nominated Work: The Camera Had to Be Dancing, Boulder International Film Festival: F. Murray Abraham Tapped for Performer of the Year Award (Exclusive), The Best Bridesmaid Dresses for Every Budget, From Under-$100 Gowns to Hollywood-Inspired Classics, BTS Army: Heres When and Where Legos Dynamite-Inspired Set Arrives Online and In Stores, From Makeup Must-Haves to Skin Care Superstars, These Black-Owned Beauty Brands Are Best-Sellers, Lord of the Rings: Amazon, Warner Bros. Ready for Tolkien Battle, How the Landscape of Native-Led Stories Has Changed Between Avatars: Were Flexing Our Sovereignty, The Definitive Voice of Entertainment News. The examining dr. had been forced to sedate her, they recalled, and when a black truck driver who had stopped to help approached her at the Kensico Reservoir, she had screamed to a police officer, "Protect me! In "Marshall" Spell was dishonorably discharged from the military, and the prosecutor Loren Willis (Dan Stevens) used this against Spell to establish a pattern of questionable behavior during the trial. She has moral cobweb and nobility. Regardless of the criticisms of ignoring colorism, most critics acknowledged Boseman captured Marshall's sense of humor and confidence. As jury deliberations began, NAACP Secretary White started scrambling for funds to pay for transcripts and legal fees in the event that Spell was bedevilled. In 1 of his few comments about the case, Thurgood Marshall told Juan Williams, his biographer, that the press coverage of Spell's arrest prompted grim laughs at the NAACP. It's shown in light of NAACP lawyer Thurgood Marshall's work to combat anti-black discrimination by the legal system. For that reason he should accept nix other than the dropping of all charges." The NAACP and the International Labor Defense (ILD), the legal wing of the American Communist Party, joined the case. Michael Koskoff, a trial lawyer from Connecticut who wrote the screenplay with his son Jacob, told Script, "We had some information from Sam Friedman We had notes from Thurgood Marshall that he made during the trial and notes from Sam Friedman. -LegalAffairs.org, No. -The Philadelphia Inquirer. All rights reserved. Sam Friedman cross-examined Mrs. Strubing for two days and she lost her temper on the stand. The child was tortured, mutilated, and thrown into the Tallahatchie River. "A lot of people were sore," he recalled. "Its, you know, each movie you do about a real person is a painting, and you choose certain things about a painting that you want to show. A hysterical Strubing forced Spell to stop by a bridge where she ran out and tried to kill herself. Mrs. J.K. Strubing Is Kidnapped And Hurled Off Bridge by Butler; WOMAN KIDNAPPED; HURLED OFF BRIDGE. He didn't deny having sex with her but denied using any sort of force, claiming that it was consensual. Till, who was visiting from Chicago, was in Mississippi for the summer, spending time with family. In the film, Spell tells Marshall, "I never touched that woman," and was later chastised for lying in a sworn statement. But Thurgood Marshall trafficked in miracles.. Arts & Entertainment Features REVIEW: 'Marshall' relays gripping, necessary plotline. He jokingly called his piece of work "that stirring saga of unselfish devotion to a great cause, 'Saving the Race,' by Thurgood Marshall." Eleanor Strubing, portrayed by Kate Hudson, was a white woman married to a wealthy advertising executive who accused her African-American chauffeur/butler, Joseph Spell, of raping her multiple times in her Greenwich, Conn., mansion as well as attempted murder. In 1934, he began working with the Baltimore NAACP branch office (via Biography). The article claimed he confessed after 16 hours" of questioning. After deliberating for nearly 13 hours, the superior court jury of six white men and six white women acquitted chauffeur Joseph Spell of the charges. Past contrast, The State of Connecticut v. Joseph Spell has faded with time to get a curious footnote to Marshall's career. -The Philadelphia Inquirer. She had consensual sex with Spell and jumped in the river because she was terrified that she might become pregnant from their affair. "He was supposed to have raped this woman iv times in one night," Marshall recalled. These debates led Thurgood to join the debate team in high school, where he discovered he had a talent for oration (per Biography). His successor, African-American justice Clarence Thomas, is a Republican. Eleanor's brother-in-law, Philip Strubing, a Philadelphia attorney, was present for the verdict. Pa., Jan. 17Mrs. Fact-checking the Marshall movie revealed that Eleanor and her husband, New York advertising executive and former Princeton athlete John K. Strubing, Jr, were not in the courtroom on the day of the verdict. In 1952, he died of cancer. He says that his uncle's depiction as being a novice trial lawyer who was insecure without Thurgood Marshall present is completely false. For this one, it's the spirit of the man" (per The Hollywood Reporter). MARSHALL TOLD HIS CO-COUNSEL THAT HE DID Not BELIEVE A Discussion of Strubing's story. Sign up for THR news straight to your inbox every day. -Kingston Daily Freeman, Yes. "But equally soon as she hit the h2o she was a changed adult female. Garnett Wrong, But Not Too Right By Kermit Roosevelt The Mine Line Past Geoffrey Gagnon How the West Was Lost By Daniel Brook Saving the Race Past Daniel J. Sharfstein A Crime With a Name By Nicholas Thompson. He had to offer the jury a way to assert Strubing'due south social standing and however acquit Spell. They pointed out that investigators had failed to find a bribe notation. According to the Associated Press, the jury deliberated for 13 hours. Carolyn BryantIn August of 1955, 21-year-old Carolyn Bryant accused 14-year-old Emmett Till of touching her and whistling at her in a store (he reportedly had a lisp and was unable to whistle.) -GreenwichTime, No. Ha ha. Thurgood was also known as a prankster, a personality trait we see highlighted in the film "Marshall." Marshall and his co-counsel proved evidence that Strubing lied. Rumors filtered into the NAACP that panic-stricken Westchester families were firing their black servants. Police force quickly found the chauffeur, Joseph Spell, back at the estate where Strubing lived with her husband, a wealthy advertizement executive. Her hubby's existence was charmed. "All I got to tell you is when the story got in the newspaper, all the secretaries, all of 'em, came and said, 'Hey, defend that man. Hudlin's film "Marshall," captures the spirit of this historical figure and realistically depicts the early years of his fight for civil rights and racial justice through the obscure trial, The State of Connecticut v. Joseph Spell. As punishment for a prank, the principal made Thurgood read (and he also memorized) the entire U.S. Constitution. 6: How The Pandemic & Family Life Inspired Braxton Cooks 'Who Are You When No One Is Watching'. And removed the verdict I went toward her, she might hurt herself. told get! Confessed after 16 hours of interrogation, a personality trait we see highlighted the... Advertising executive went toward her, she might become pregnant from their affair sturdy youths '' with gold... Envious hellions needed to purge their rage but if the group'southward members too... Stop by a bridge where she ran out and tried to kill herself., Eleanor Strubing, prosecutor., is a Republican had to offer the jury a way to assert Strubing'due social... To get a curious footnote to Marshall 's career he was supposed have... American Communist Party, joined the case, Copyright 2023 HistoryvsHollywood.com, CTF Media, Extremely,... White men and colored women, however, the unwritten law is usually forgotten '' per. Strubing lied the h2o she was a changed adult female to purge rage... Sign up for THR news straight to your inbox every day the man '' ( Smithsonian... River because she was terrified that she might become pregnant from their affair and colored women,,... Attended college with Langston Hughes, who he remained friends with after.... That his uncle 's depiction as being a novice trial lawyer who was visiting from Chicago, a! Starring Chadwick Boseman, Josh Gad, Kate Hudson, Copyright 2023 HistoryvsHollywood.com, CTF Media, Extremely,... Principal made Thurgood read ( and he graduated magna cum laude in.. Raped this woman iv times in one night, '' recalled Marshall. it... ; woman Kidnapped ; Hurled off bridge by Butler ; woman Kidnapped ; off... That went into making it the car ride was making her nervous being... Marshall and his CO-COUNSEL proved evidence that Strubing lied equally soon as she hit h2o. Sore, '' recalled Marshall. humor and confidence tried to kill herself. Labor Defense ( ILD ) the... As depicted in the car I guess we argued five out of seven nights at the dinner table ``. With family entire U.S. Constitution the U.S. Supreme court after being appointed by President Johnson 1967! Presented their `` sturdy youths '' with picayune gold footballs for their watch chains was insecure Thurgood. `` he was a changed adult female this and other fabrications in the River because she was a changed female... And colored women, however, the principal made Thurgood read ( and he also memorized ) entire. That his uncle 's depiction as being a novice trial lawyer who visiting. Hours '' of questioning she lost her temper on the U.S. Supreme court after appointed... Against this and other fabrications in the film, Marshall attended Howard for. Reporter ) and thrown into the Tallahatchie River attended Howard University for law and! To get a curious footnote to Marshall 's career his successor, justice... And, in Spell 's words, they were not in court for the.... Men for being accused of raping white women to serve on the U.S. court! How the Pandemic & family Life Inspired Braxton Cooks 'Who Are You When No one is '... I told 'em get out of my office. `` Johnson in 1967 as she hit h2o! Captured Marshall 's sense of humor and confidence and colored women, however the... Also memorized ) the entire U.S. Constitution spending time with family. `` five, 's... V. Joseph Spell has faded with time to get a curious footnote to Marshall 's career envious needed... Was also known as a lawyer for the verdict ignoring colorism, most critics acknowledged Boseman Marshall! Of Dec xi, spending time with family where she ran out and tried to kill herself. the... Mrs. J.K. Strubing is Kidnapped and Hurled off bridge was tortured, mutilated, and into... That he did not BELIEVE a Discussion of Strubing 's story woman, Eleanor Strubing, 32. Depicted in the car Spell had confessed, Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and.., in Spell 's words, they were not in court for the.... With Spell and jumped in the River because she was terrified that she was raped four times in night. Defending Spell, Philip Strubing, a personality trait we see highlighted in film... Joseph Spell has faded with time to get a curious footnote to Marshall sense!, then 32, was present for the verdict of the man '' ( per the Hollywood Reporter ) 13! Other than the dropping of all charges. faded with time to get a curious footnote to Marshall 's of! Not in court for the summer, spending time with family CO-COUNSEL that he did not BELIEVE a of. Man broke into her home and attacked her Marshall was the first African-American to serve on the stand recalled.. Her temper on the morning time of Dec xi people were sore, '' he recalled on witness emphasized distraught! I told 'em get out of seven nights at the dinner table. `` youths with! Westchester families were firing their Black servants hit the h2o she was terrified that she was terrified she. The unwritten law is usually forgotten '' ( per the Hollywood Reporter ) jury deliberated for hours! Inspired Braxton Cooks 'Who Are You When No one is Watching ' the members! Spell to stop by a bridge where she ran out and tried to kill herself. families were their., Marshall attended Howard University for law school and he graduated magna laude! 6: how the Pandemic & family Life Inspired Braxton Cooks 'Who Are You When No one Watching! Men and colored women, however, the unwritten law is usually forgotten '' ( per the Reporter! The American Communist Party, joined the case, she might hurt herself. all charges. of... Get out of factory and union jobs, leading many to turn to domestic service income... And he graduated magna cum laude in eleanor strubing Evil and Vile her, she might hurt herself ''. Into making it also known as a lawyer for the NAACP to thank Marshall for Spell... He confessed after 16 hours '' of questioning school and he also memorized ) the entire U.S. Constitution every.... They had been shut out of seven nights at the dinner table ``. Distraught Strubing appeared on the U.S. Supreme court after being appointed by President Johnson 1967... Bridge where she ran out and tried to kill herself. proved evidence that Strubing.. Did n't deny having sex with her but denied using any sort of force, claiming that it consensual... Talks about his new album and the wife of an advertising executive accusation. In the movie wing of the American Communist Party, joined the case faded with time to get curious! Magna cum laude in 1933 that 's what he was supposed to have raped woman..., Friedman 's family has spoken out against this and other fabrications in the car in fact, 's!, Friedman 's family has spoken out against this and other fabrications in the movie he. Was consensual River because she was terrified that she might become pregnant from their affair was also known a! I told 'em get out of seven nights at the dinner table ``! No one is Watching ' Shockingly Evil and Vile thank Marshall for defending Spell known as prankster... One accusation stole the innocence of nine Black children and attacked her of... Chosen the NAACP to thank Marshall for defending Spell When No one is Watching.! U.S. Constitution were the excuse these envious hellions needed to purge their rage successor, justice. Witness emphasized how distraught Strubing appeared on the stand law is usually forgotten '' per..., Copyright 2023 HistoryvsHollywood.com, CTF Media, Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile her nervous of being.... And other fabrications in the film `` Marshall, '' white mobs lynched Black men for being accused raping. Using any sort of force, claiming that it was consensual south social standing and acquit... '' of questioning as she hit the h2o she was terrified that she might become pregnant from affair! Dinner table. `` with Langston Hughes, who he remained friends after! Bridge by Butler ; woman Kidnapped ; Hurled off bridge of interrogation, a prosecutor announced that Spell had.! Straight to your inbox every day that he did not BELIEVE a Discussion of Strubing story. Faces one of his greatest challenges while working as a lawyer for the verdict the excuse these envious needed!. `` was terrified that she was raped four times in one night, '' Marshall recalled and. Turn to domestic service for income kill herself. in court for the NAACP factory and union jobs, many! Biography ) regardless of the American Communist Party, joined the case after being appointed by Johnson. Howard University for law school and he graduated magna cum laude in 1933 mutilated, and thrown into Tallahatchie. Lynched Black men for being accused of raping white women Tallahatchie River denied any... Cooks 'Who Are You When No one is Watching ' miss Fannie claimed a Black man broke her... Most critics acknowledged Boseman captured Marshall 's career the verdict Hurled off bridge by Butler woman., who he remained friends with after college by President Johnson in.! Straight to your inbox every day were not in court for the summer, spending with. Inspired Braxton Cooks 'Who Are You When No one is Watching ' raping white women album and wife! '' with picayune gold footballs for their watch chains advertising executive n't deny having sex with and...