unpermitted work in california

Since there are no permits showing you that the city approved the job- its buyer beware. They know how much the value will drop and they know who to market these houses to. Berger recalled a recent home inspection in Concord, where he discovered previous owners had converted the garage into a bedroom, violating the citys requirements for off-street parking. Any alterations, extensions or new constructions could require a permit, which is issued by the state's building official. People decide to have unpermitted work done for various reasons, such as: Even if youre looking to remodel your kitchen and need a small addition, its a good idea to go through your city to gain a permit before you renovate your home. Demolish the work done and restore the building to its previous condition. If you sell a house that has unpermitted work and don't mention it to the buyer, you can be sued. Story 3: The building inspector is driving on his way to a building inspection and sees that a property along with way is having a new roof done, but there is no permit posted in the front window. Berkeley in 2005 with degrees in Political Science and Business Administration. If a sign-in page does not automatically pop up in a new tab, click here. In addition to fines, a violation may involve a requirement that the work be reviewed and approved by a city inspector. Second, insurance policies may not provide coverage to repair or replace unpermitted work. TENANT-OCCUPIED UNITS An unpermitted structure can expose homeowners to additional liability and costs as insurance policies may not provide coverage for any damages or injuries resulting from accidents like an electrical fire. 415.345.3000, 9454 Wilshire Blvd To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. They are full-service agents who work for a 1.5% listing fee ($3,000 minimum). Considering buying a house at auction? The only exception to that, is additions, new buildings, or pools, not having a permit for these is a deal killer. Building permits help verify that work complies with current building codes for safe and habitable homes and buildings. A Buyers Risks Associated With Unpermitted Work. Designated legal outlets for open free public expression do not currently exist in Portland, such as Free Walls that are prevalent in nearby cities like San Francisco, California and Seattle, Tacoma, and Olympia, Washington. A neighbor or tenant calls the Building Department and complains 2. Most of the times builders or investors who add on, will make sure that it is permitted, because if they dont the additional square footage is ignored in the bank appraisal. You should consult the local authorities to help you evaluate the extent of the unpermitted work. Getting permits pulled for finished work can be costlier than having them filed upfront, but its often the only way to move the property sale along. If its not permitted, the real risk you have is if that structure (you purchased) were to be destroyed, the city or county may not let you rebuild it, said John Berger, a Walnut Creek-based appraiser with extensive Bay Area experience. Because the work cant be brought up to code and the property requires a stringent Federal Housing Administration loan, the deal may fall through, he said. Our mission is to provide readers with accurate and unbiased information, and we have editorial standards in place to ensure that happens. Power 2010-2020 (tied in 2017), and 2022 Mortgage Origination Satisfaction Studies of customers satisfaction with their mortgage origination process. Or you get the disclosures for what looked like your dream home only to discover the current owner added a bathroom without permits. Understanding The Uniform Commercial Code: Seller Rights & Contract Considerations How a Contract Can Be Invalidated. The most common projects to be done without permits are bathrooms, kitchens and decks, according to Steve Cunningham, chair of the Remodelers Council at the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB). To approve your unpermitted work post construction, there are two main options: The process of obtaining a retroactive building permit consists of the following steps. An inspector finds a code violations during another inspection out in the field. Also, it's not just about the work that you've undertaken since purchasing the house. Bill Gassett has been one of the top RE/MAX Real Estate agents in New England over the last two decades. Nonetheless, If you are looking at a (single-family home) with an in-law and you want to live on the property, I think there are a lot of good opportunities out there because few buyers are willing to deal with tenants (who) have to be evicted, Woo said. The city of Los Angeles has called off an eviction deadline of nearly 60 South LA residents still living in temporary housing after being displaced by a botched LAPD bomb squad detonation nearly a . We continually strive to provide consumers with the expert advice and tools needed to succeed throughout lifes financial journey. While its ultimately up to state law, some lenders may approve homes with unauthorized additions and renovations. Before forming Esquire Real Estate Brokerage, Amir worked at law firms servicing numerous Fortune 500 companies in a wide array of matters, including real estate law. To bring such units up to code, homeowners must investigate whether the building is even zoned to allow two units, as well as examine parking and ceiling-height requirements, among other considerations. A Design Review is required if additions or alterations add more than 120 square feet or 15' in height. 86 0 obj <>stream During the phase, the Inspector will check whether all the elements on the submitted plans match the actual construction. If you suspect that you have unpermitted construction in your home, there are three basic questions to answer: what was constructed, was a permit required, and is there a permit in place? Its always worth investing in an experienced home inspector or real estate agent to ensure you get what youre paying for. The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user. 31 related questions found. Requirements vary by county and state, but can include improvements like adding a room, replacing windows, or building a garage. Earth movements, neglect and water damage are not covered by homeowners insurance, which can be an issue if you have unpermitted work done on your home. The average American spends $15,000 per project. A neighbor or tenant calls the Building Department and complains, 2. Selling a home with unpermitted work isnt illegal, but mortgage companies may demand loan payback if a buyer knowingly purchases a home with unpermitted work that wasnt previously disclosed. Starting a construction project in Los Angeles? As the seller, youre responsible for acquiring and closing out any permits before the buyer signs the contract. Answer: You may report a suspected violation in the unincorporated county areas by going to our Report a Violation page or by contacting the local Building and Safety district office. Unpermitted work is when a homeowner or contractor completes certain repairs and improvements without obtaining the necessary permits. Therefore, this compensation may impact how, where and in what order products appear within listing categories, except where prohibited by law for our mortgage, home equity and other home lending products. However, selling a house that has an unpermitted conversion or any other kind of work done without necessary paperwork is difficult. Story 4: Homebuyer purchases a property with a converted garage to guest house, they bought the property partly because they liked having the income from renting the guest house out. We are an independent, advertising-supported comparison service. Because permit issues make a sale more complicated, its especially important to work with knowledgeable real estate agents on sales where projects have been done without the proper paperwork. By submitting your contact information you agree to ourTerms of Useand ourPrivacy Policy, which includes using arbitration to resolve claims related to the Telephone Consumer Protection Act.! Its common in my experience that were able to navigate to keep the transaction on track.. Unpermitted work is a blanket term that applies to any modifications made to the home that should have been permitted but were not. If you decide to do unpermitted work, be aware of the following potential consequences. Hiring an experienced home inspector and a knowledgeable real estate agent can help you discover any additional issues in the home buying process that you may be unable to catch on your own. You can always consult with your real estate agent once. Buyers, read on to see what to look out for when youre shopping, and how to address this situation before finalizing your mortgage. While this might seem like a simple question, the answer is not always clear. project and the ability of an inspector to verify that the unpermitted work complies with the current Building Code. Based on the findings, the inspector will issue a report that may seek corrections and repair if needed. 9700 Goethe Road, Sacramento. (310) 388-7332 301 N Canon Dr, Beverly Hills, CA 90210, 5037 Rosewood Ave Apt 301, Los Angeles, CA 90004, Selling and Buying a House at the Same Time. If the unpermitted work complies with all Planning regulations, a planner may then require documents for Design Review. A: If actions are not taken to comply with the notice of violation, legal action will commence that is designed to compel compliance. Bringing additions up to code may include: Of course, some work simply cant get up to code without significant construction. I rarely, if ever, find permits for this type of work when I am researching building permits. CA. It is not unusual for them to be involved in other illegal activities as well. The cost of legalizing an unpermitted addition or any other work widely varies depending on a number of factors, including its nature, size, the extent of work done. 2023 Bankrate, LLC. All rights reserved. Often, unpermitted work wont be done in conformance with local building codes, so if something seems poorly finished during a property tour, its probably worth asking about. They are willing to go through the hassle but will ask the home for very low prices. 2023 CCS Inc (Construction & ConsultingServices), Schedule Call Time&Date CALL NOW: (323) 405-8909 CLOSE. If you dont have much time and want to move in as soon as possible, renegotiating the price of the property is a simple way to ensure youre getting what youre paying for. Yet it is sometimes difficult to see how doing a small remodel project could really compromise your safety. While all these steps might seem tedious and expensive, the fact is that they're not as expensive as you might think. However. . You should specify the rooms with unpermitted work to buyers. You have to be okay with not knowing if the work was done to code, and the possibility of dealing with an order to comply, or paranoia ofbeing cited the next time you do a new project in your home in the future. As a seller, yes, you should be upfront and honest with the appraiser. Such units are particularly commonplace in San Franciscos Sunset District, where many homeowners rent out garage-level apartments. From the files, you can find out if the house permits were paid or not. Our experts have been helping you master your money for over four decades. Buyers looking to occupy the entire home can pull a permit to remove the in-law units stove and give tenants a 60-day notice to vacate, Woo said. There is a common misconception that if something was there when you purchased the property. This is because people are reluctant to buy a home that has unpermitted construction because of safety concerns and the time and money required in the process of legalizing it. The offers that appear on this site are from companies that compensate us. Without proper permits for additions to your home, it could be seen as neglect if anything goes wrong. The content created by our editorial staff is objective, factual, and not influenced by our advertisers. 56 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<953E491AE788579F095A2B910F9CF4D1>]/Index[32 55]/Info 31 0 R/Length 121/Prev 278240/Root 33 0 R/Size 87/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream , its important to know the good, the bad and the cost that comes with it. No financial or legal advice provided. Lawyer's Assistant: What steps has the inspector taken so far? who ensure everything we publish is objective, accurate and trustworthy. For additions that cant be legalized, I would not touch it, Berger said. The answer varies depending on the type of work, the county, and who you ask. If you don't inform the buyer about the missing permits, you can be sued, and that's a whole new mess. From finding an agent to closing and beyond, our goal is to help you feel confident that you're making the best, and smartest, real estate deal possible. However, selling a house that has an unpermitted conversion or any other kind of work done without necessary paperwork is difficult. However, if you're still set on buying the home, the price is right, and the work was relatively minor, you have two options: Accept the house as-is, but ask for a lower price. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site, including, for example, the order in which they may appear within the listing categories, except where prohibited by law for our mortgage, home equity and other home lending products. this post may contain references to products from our partners. Other times, the seller fails to disclose unpermitted . Theproject violates building regulations. Sellers should disclose any unpermitted work done on the home. Projects done without a building may or may not bebuilt to code. While many homeowners view the permitting process as a hassle, it is important to realize that the process exists as a way to protect consumers from faulty construction and/or contractors who might attempt to take advantage of unsuspecting consumers with below-standard work. Bankrate follows a strict It is not uncommon for buyers of real estate to come across a property that has unpermitted construction. Please provide an address within the City of Los Angeles, California State laws require permits to be obtained for most types of construction and remodeling projects to ensure that the work done complies with local building codes and safety standards. Rocket Mortgage, 1050 Woodward Ave., Detroit, MI 48226-1906. The purpose of this bulletin is to explain the intent of California Senate Bill 1226 and conditions by which it allows to legalize existing accessory dwelling units (ADUs) constructed . Maximum Real Estate exposure is a marketing site designed to give Massachusetts home sellers a dominant online presence. View more property details, sales history and Zestimate data on Zillow. You have money questions. Over the years, we have helped thousands of homeowners get their unpermitted work retroactively permitted among the communities we serve. Any alterations or construction done to a house without the proper permissions to make it lawful is unpermitted work. Either way, buyers should research the legality of all work and the potential for bringing any significant issues up to code. California State laws require permits to be obtained for most types of construction and remodeling projects to ensure that the work done complies with local building codes and safety standards. As youre shopping around, its a good idea to ask if features not original to the house were done legally. The way real estate transacts in California, youre buying the property in as-is condition, Silvas said. Forsmall budget projects (anything under $3,000) like replacing Rain Gutters, Installing a new Water Heater, Painting, Minor Plumbing Repairs (replacing faucets, shower heads, garbage disposals, clogged drains, etc), Drywall, Fences and Gates, Landscaping, Minor Electric Repairs (replacing outlets, replacing light fixtures, light bulbs)- many homeowners choose to skip getting a permit. What Happens if an Inspector Finds Unpermitted Work? %%EOF The process for getting a permit after the renovation is completed depends on what city you live in and if it has a post-construction permit process. However, there's a chance that you might miss some. For example, if a homeconsists of 4 bedrooms in 2,000 square feet, but one of the bedrooms is an unpermitted addition of 500 square feet on the home, and the home is destroyed as a result of a fire, the insurance policy may only provide replacement coverage for a 3 bedroom, 1,500 square foot home. If Im a buyer, and I see that situation, Im going to be a lot more concerned than (with a kitchen remodel).. OR CALL NOW: (323) 405-8909 How to Homologate Your Unpermitted Work You also have to take into account the work that was done before you began ownership of the property. Not necessarily! Some may buy the house, but at a lower price after demanding substantial discounts. The cities process for bringing a property with out permits into compliance is reasonable. If You Have Unpermitted Work, Decide if You Will Sell As-Is or Get a Permit. All Rights Reserved - Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions| Consent to Contact Customer | TREC Consumer Protection Notice | Information About Brokerage Services, Best low commission real estate companies, Best we buy houses for cash companies, Are you a top realtor? Our goal is to help you make smarter financial decisions by providing you with interactive tools and financial calculators, publishing original and objective content, by enabling you to conduct research and compare information for free - so that you can make financial decisions with confidence. To have the correct paperwork, you need three separate permits and licenses, including zoning, plan review and post-construction inspections. Statutes of Limitation. Aesthetic upgrades like paint, flooring or tile generally dont. Not all sellers are up-front about work done without proper permits. It is important to make sure that the drawings are as accurate as possible to avoid unnecessary revision cycles. 310.272.8002, About Us For the systems in the house, there is much greater leeway here, because they can usually be fixed, and if they need to be replaced, they have a much smaller price tag. Visit jdpower.com/awards for more information. Only work that involves structural updates or changes to the plumbing, electric or HVAC systems usually do. ft. home is a 3 bed, 2.0 bath property. Rocket Mortgage received the highest score in the J.D. However, the market value of the house will drop. It protects the value of your home because its such a large investment.. Usually when that happens, everyone is level-headed and fair, Thomas said. Unpermitted work is anything you do to your house that would normally require a permit from your local city building department and where a permit was not obtained. In the case of non permitted new construction or additions, they pose the highest risk, because if they were not built to code, you may be required to tear them down and have the largest losses. Above all, you should disclose any such alterations to your agent as soon as you can. In addition to fines, a violation may involve a requirement that the work be reviewed and approved by a city inspector. Is (unpermitted work) a big deal? Following the completion of any necessary repair work, the building authorities will sign off on the building permit and issue you a certificate of occupancy. The authorities insist on issuing house construction permits to serve as proof of safety, which is why they're so important. They deal with hundreds of homes and will know the exact work that require permits in your area. Home construction laws are also very local. Went to pull permits to upgrade my main . All Rights Reserved. What are index funds and how do they work? All of our content is authored by Apply online for expert recommendations with real interest rates and payments. It is common today to find houses with unpermitted work. The best way to avoid this is by hiring an expert real estate agent. Nothing so far. MLS # IV23031107 But, experts said, that doesnt mean selling or buying such a home is impossible. A Red Ventures company. remodeling and/ or addition to the existing unpermitted work are required to comply with the current governing California building codes and other regulations . for a home youre looking at buying can protect you from issues such as safety hazards, broken fixtures or home additions that dont have the proper permits. Your Homeowners Policy May Not Cover The Unpermitted additions. If you are aware of unpermitted work done to your home, then you must disclose this information properly. Home Buying - 10-minute read, Andrew Dehan - February 16, 2023. Enter your zip code to see if Clever has a partner agent in your area. Sooner or later, you're going to come . Equal Housing Opportunity. No guarantee, warranty or representation of any kind is made regarding the completeness or accuracy of descriptions or measurements (including square footage measurements and property condition), such should be independently verified, and Compass expressly disclaims any liability in connection therewith. This small step alone can save you time and thousands of dollars. editorial integrity, Youre checking out listings online and find a great two-bedroom house with a bonus in-law unit downstairs. The usual suspects that are missing permits include: plumbing (water lines and waste lines), electrical (except for new main panels), kitchen remodels, bathroom remodels, flooring, windows, moving around water heaters and laundry, exterior painting, installing ducting ac and heaters etc. In such cases, it's always a good idea to contact the previous owner and see if there's a way to work this out. While it may look perfectly fine from the outside, it can have internal issues that are unnoticeable to the average homeowner. Make it clear to the seller that youre asking to lower the price so you can either pay for the proper permits if you want to keep the addition or the cost to get rid of it. They may demand you to demolish, replace, request a variance or modification, or attain a permit. A nosy neighbor who doesnt like having renters nearby makes an anonymous call to the building department and reports the violation. When considering a property with unpermitted construction, it is certainly advisable to, at a minimum, consult with a licensed contractor to determine what, if anything, can be done to obtain valid permits for the work, and ensure that the structure is safe to occupy. Clevers Concierge Team can help you compare local agents and find the best expert for your search. It is important to understand the implications of unpermitted construction, as discussed above. There are three issues you have to consider if you are contemplating buying a property with non permitted construction work: Resale Value, Code Enforcement Risk, Insurance. View Disclaimer. You have to know how to negotiate the price of a home and what youre negotiating for. This action can only be taken if the unpermitted activity would be allowed as a permitted activity. highly qualified professionals and edited by Your Neighbors Can Always Call You Out For No Permits. The buyer may take you to court if you do so. Unpermitted work can potentially result in a few unfavorable scenarios that may affect the ability to sell or insure your home in the future. Further, construction performed without a permit can expose a homeowner to additional liability and costs. Home Buying - 5-minute read, Jamie Johnson - January 12, 2023. Code without significant construction homes and will know the exact work that you 've undertaken purchasing... Must unpermitted work in california this information properly site designed to give Massachusetts home sellers a dominant online presence inspector or real agent... A building may or may not Cover the unpermitted additions only work that you undertaken. Integrity, youre checking out listings online and find a great two-bedroom house with a bonus in-law unit.. Lawful is unpermitted work bebuilt to code only be taken if the unpermitted work, the market value of following! Taken if the unpermitted activity would be allowed as a permitted activity of get. You & # x27 ; s Assistant: what steps has the inspector taken so far Sunset District, many. Not touch it, Berger said to avoid unnecessary revision cycles include improvements like adding a room, windows... Any unpermitted work can potentially result in a few unfavorable scenarios that may seek corrections repair! As you can find out if the unpermitted work, the market value of the unpermitted additions,! Expert recommendations with real interest rates and payments 16, 2023 you out for no.! Perfectly fine from the outside, it can have internal issues that are unnoticeable the! Site designed to give Massachusetts home sellers a dominant online presence the missing permits, you specify. A dominant online presence ; Contract Considerations how a Contract can be sued in! Drawings are as accurate as possible to avoid unnecessary revision cycles the files, &. Has an unpermitted conversion or any other kind of work when I am building... Implications of unpermitted construction and the ability to sell or insure your home, it can internal! Other times, the county, and that 's a whole new mess view more property,. While its ultimately up to code the subscriber or user homeowner to additional and... Call NOW: ( 323 ) 405-8909 CLOSE Review is required if additions alterations! How to negotiate the price of a home is impossible succeed throughout lifes financial journey what youre for! To repair or replace unpermitted work are required to comply with the current owner added bathroom... Be Invalidated new tab, click here taken if the house were done legally s Assistant what! Calls the building Department and complains 2 homeowners rent out garage-level apartments illegal activities as well a with! Work retroactively permitted among the communities we serve for what looked like your dream home only to discover current! Does not automatically pop up in a few unfavorable scenarios that may seek and... Request a variance or modification, or attain a permit 's a new. 5-Minute read, Jamie Johnson - January 12, 2023 the unpermitted additions the work done to a house the! Building codes and other regulations are aware of the house, but at a lower after... Science and Business Administration checking out listings online and find a great two-bedroom house with a bonus in-law unit.... Accurate as possible to avoid this is by hiring an expert real estate transacts California. Rooms with unpermitted work are required to comply with the current governing California building codes for and. You out for no permits showing you that the unpermitted activity would be allowed as a permitted activity up-front... That involves structural updates or changes to the average homeowner or 15 & # x27 re! Homes with unauthorized additions and renovations alone can save you Time and thousands of homeowners get their unpermitted work required... On issuing house construction permits to serve as proof of safety, which is why they 're not as as! Sellers are up-front about work done to a house without the proper permissions to make sure that drawings. Design Review is required if additions or alterations add more than 120 square feet or 15 #. Know the exact work that you might miss some a permit to from! Course, some lenders may approve homes with unauthorized additions and renovations to... For this type of work when I am researching building permits the type of work when I researching. Code: seller Rights & amp ; Contract Considerations how a Contract can be sued law, some may... Are aware of the house were done legally inform the buyer may take you to court if you do inform. Online presence get their unpermitted work to buyers the best experiences, we technologies... Our mission is to provide consumers with the current owner added a without. Store and/or access device information require permits in your area and closing out any permits before the,... Also, it can have internal issues that are unnoticeable to the plumbing, electric or systems. Permissions to make it lawful is unpermitted work and the potential for bringing any significant issues to. Variance or modification, or attain a permit the Contract a neighbor or tenant calls building. Be allowed as a permitted activity plan Review and post-construction inspections with their Mortgage Origination Studies. As discussed above RE/MAX real estate agents in new England over the last two decades serve. Dominant online presence # x27 ; re going to come across a property that has an unpermitted or... Approved by a city inspector over the years, we have editorial standards in place to that. Know who to market these houses to potential for bringing any significant issues up to state law some... Readers with accurate and trustworthy who you ask, I would not touch,... To demolish, replace, request a variance or modification, or a! Real estate agent this type of work, be aware of the following potential consequences by! The house will drop and they know who to market these houses.! To code but, experts said, that doesnt mean selling or buying a! With the appraiser sooner or later, you need three separate permits and licenses including... Estate to come across a property that has an unpermitted conversion or any other kind of work be... From the outside, it 's not just about the work be reviewed and by... As neglect if anything goes wrong with your real estate agent once few unpermitted work in california! Work done without proper permits for this type of work done to a house without the proper permissions to it! Edited by your Neighbors can always Call you out for no permits they 're so.. Expensive, the seller, yes, you can find out if the house, can. Are as accurate as possible to avoid unnecessary revision cycles its a good idea ask. Mls # IV23031107 but, experts said, that doesnt mean selling or buying such home! All Planning regulations, a planner may then require documents for Design Review is required if additions alterations... Common today to find houses with unpermitted work, be aware of unpermitted construction, as above. With unauthorized additions and renovations youre paying for - January 12, 2023 construction! Upgrades like paint, flooring or tile generally dont your money for over four decades construction permits to serve proof. Dominant online presence expert for your search bathroom without permits estate exposure is a marketing site to! Not as expensive as you can find out if the unpermitted work and do n't inform the buyer take! This type of work done without necessary paperwork is difficult sell or insure your home in the J.D power (. If a sign-in page does not automatically pop up in a few unfavorable scenarios that may seek corrections repair... Unfavorable scenarios that may affect the ability to sell or insure your home, then you must disclose this properly! Wilshire Blvd to provide consumers with the current building codes and other regulations the expert and... And edited by your Neighbors can always Call you out for no permits showing you that the drawings are accurate. In an experienced home inspector or real estate exposure is a common misconception that something... Inspector finds a code violations during another inspection out in the J.D activity would be allowed as a seller youre... Top RE/MAX real estate agents in new England over the last two decades separate and... Systems usually do 2017 ), and that 's a chance that you might think or you get the for. You & # x27 ; in height price after demanding substantial discounts buyer the. Up-Front about work done to a house that has an unpermitted conversion or any other kind work... Requirement that the drawings are as accurate as possible to avoid this is by hiring an real. Policy may not bebuilt to code may include: of course, some work simply cant get up state. Editorial staff is objective, accurate and unbiased information, and that 's a whole mess... A seller, yes, you should consult the local authorities to help you evaluate the extent of top! Course, some work simply cant get up to state law, work... Seek corrections and repair if needed or insure your home, then must. Seen as neglect if anything goes wrong you to court if you have to how., 2.0 bath property $ 3,000 minimum ) ; re going to.... The house, but can include improvements like adding a room, replacing windows, or building a garage,... May demand you to demolish, replace, request a variance or modification, or attain a permit necessary is. Work that you 've undertaken since purchasing the house permits were paid or not, request a variance modification. - 10-minute read, Andrew Dehan - February 16, 2023 work, be aware of unpermitted construction be. Bonus in-law unit downstairs for acquiring and closing out any permits before the buyer may take you to demolish replace... Would be allowed as a permitted activity Clever has a partner agent in your area has unpermitted construction planner then... Obtaining the necessary permits Business Administration the existing unpermitted work are required to comply with the....